What I Do:Reviewing Comics
Assalamu’alaikum to the Muslim readers
A Good Day to the non-Muslim readers!
Bismillahirrahamanirrahim
After reblogging things below,I finally remembered what I planned to do…(Haha)
This is probably a post tht will be referred a lot in my future comic review posts since I think it is very important to state how I review things.I mean,if you don’t know what I review is based upon.It will be like,me not knowing that this person actually likes Lady Gaga because she has catchy musics and since I dun like catchy musics,I got tricked into listening to her song…Yeah
So without further ado,shall we begin?
1.Format
I am sure many of you probably have understood the structure,but anyways,why not just talk about it yeah?(——______——-)
Title
Cover of Comic
Comic Information - Artist,Writer(If Duo/Trio),Publisher,
What to Expect - I dun know if you all realized it,but I enjoy doing this LOLS!Basically what you can call genre,but a lil bit more specific?(and fun xP)
Summary
Review
Ratings
2.Review
My review,as most can see,is separated into As A Whole,Innovation and Art(In anime,it would be animation)
For As a Whole,I will basically talk about everything,from storyline to character development and how the book is to me.Most of which is a ‘touch and go’ system which is further eleborated in Ratings
Innovation:Basically what plus side the comic has which is pretty unique(if not entirely).It can be from the drawing style to the paper quality the publisher uses or just simply the foreword(lol)
Art:Yes,the BASIC of comics.A horrid art is sad to say,unforgivable even if the storyline is epic.(But a horrid storyline with nice art is actually unforgivable too to me….).For art,I would probably point out what I like from the drawings and whether I understood the drawings or not (Srs,there are comics where I read without knowing what’s going on..Really…annoying)
3.Ratings
Another favourite of mine,rating!><
Ratings are out of five.For sequels or continuation volumes,I would rate it in the series’ context.As for Complete series,first volumes,I would rate it in it’s genre’s context
Ratings are further specified to Storyline,Character Development and Art
I also just realize I should have rated the story as a whole,or overall…*facepalms*
So my ratings for storyline,CD and art are over 5.And each value would mean:
1-Yeah,maybe the comic creator should go to classes to have someone guide and improve his weak spots.
2-More practice,reading,and the comic creator probably will make it.
3-Good,not great,not outstanding,just a bit above average
4-Great!I like~
5-Marvelous!I am battered speechless by the awesomeness
Overall ratings should be over 5 too.This rating will help readers see if the book’s worth it or well,not so worth it……
1-If you don’t mind wasting your time and money,go ahead and read it…Otherwise,you’d probably be ticked off
2-Probably entertaining if you seriously have nothing to do
3-Worth reading,not a story to recommend much,but still ok to read
4-A good comic,recommended to read
5-Magnificent,excellent,dude,this comic is flawless!READ IT!
Just thought I should mention this,but I do reviews hoping tht the artist will see this and correct the errors I mentioned or things like tht..I probably won’t review comics I hate or just finished reading cos it would probably be reviewed out of rage
If there is anything I missed out here,I probably would mention it in my reviews later…^^ Ma’as Salamah!